The scariest game in Roblox is subjective and varies based on personal preferences. However, some games stand out for their horror elements. Silent Dark is often considered one of the scariest. It won awards for Best Single-Player Game in 2016, known for its intense horror elements.
Light Bulb: Reillumination is another terrifying game. It’s a reworked version of the original Light Bulb, praised for its mix of jump scares and atmospheric horror.
Apeirophobia plays on the fear of infinity. Players find themselves in an endless environment with no clear exit, facing environmental puzzles and terrifying creatures.
Dead Silence is known for its immersive atmosphere and jump scares. It features cooperative gameplay and a mysterious storyline centered around the legend of Mary S.
Griefville: Survive the Nightmare is inspired by slasher movies. It has a day-night cycle where players must defend themselves from supernatural threats at night.